• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
  • RESOURCES
  • SUBMIT A TIP
  • WRITE FOR US
  • FORUM
  • CONTACT

Swing DJ Resources

Online magazine for Lindy Hop, Balboa, Shag & Blues DJs

  • NEWS
  • MUSIC
    • Album Releases
    • Jazz Song Alphabet
  • SONG OF THE WEEK
  • EQUIPMENT
  • SOFTWARE
  • TOOLS
  • EXPERTISE
    • Tips & Tricks
    • How To Swing DJ
    • Readers’ Questions

Modern vs. Vintage Sound: Instruments And Recording

May 30, 2014 By Adrian Seward 10 Comments

Share
Tweet
Pin
0 Shares
Victor Berton
“Hot” drummer Victor Berton

Does equipment matter?

I think it does, but I'm not talking about DJ equipment. I'm talking about the band.

First, a note of explanation. Christian has generously invited me to contribute something to this page. I do DJ, but I do not consider myself to be any sort of expert on the subject.

I do know a bit about music and history, though, and I'm always trying to figure out better ways to talk about the aspects of swing music which are so important but which almost impossible to find words for.

So, I'm going to talk about something a bit philosophical, but related to DJing.

New Cymbal Types

I recently attended a workshop given by Glenn Crytzer. He had a lot to teach, but there was one thing he said that seemed like a revelation to me. He kept talking about ride cymbals. He said that he could judge a band without hearing them, just by looking at their cymbals.

When he said this, I immediately realized what he was talking about, but I had never had the vocabulary to say what it was.

Before be-bop, cymbals were smaller and thinner. They did not have such a sustained sound. Modern drummers often use cymbals of a type which did not exist in the swing era. These have a sustained, ringing, sizzling sound.

Does it Matter?

So, is Glenn just insisting on some purist idea of authenticity? No, I don't think so. A sustained sound like a modern ride cymbal does not give a dancer the same kind of rhythmic pulse. The old cymbals, with their less sustained sound, gave a more defined beat.

I'm not saying the modern sound is always wrong, or that it can't swing, and I'm definitely not defining what is or isn't swing music… but these new tools give a different kind of rhythm and sound. This marks the music as modern.

Not Just Instruments

These kinds of problems come up with modern recording techniques as well. Standard practice today is to “close mic” each instrument. This creates a very different sound compared to old recordings where the musicians would have been standing quite a distance from the mic.

Part of this difference is a result of the microphone itself, and part of it is because the close mic-ed musician doesn't have to play as loud.

When you play a horn at a high volume, it isn't just louder, it has a different tone. (Pee Wee Erwin claimed that Bunny Berigan was 30 feet from the microphone when he recorded “Marie.” To create the tone that he did, he had to play loud!)

Processing Changes Rhythms

Another tendency is to add reverb to modern recordings. This ability did not exist in the swing era. Why does it matter? Well, rhythm is not just when a note begins, it is also when and how a note ends.

Adding reverb blurs the end of the note. This matters in music where rhythm is practically everything. It makes the rhythm less distinct. Not all modern recordings use these techniques, and I think more and more bands are taking great care about choosing which ones are appropriate.

What Should I Do About It?

Does this matter to a DJ? I think it does, but I'm not suggesting some kind of rule. Good DJs listen to each song and make a decision about how it will work for dancing.

There is a lot to it, and none of it (except BPMs) can be quantified. So I don't think it's necessary to know all of this; your ears will tell you. But I still think it's interesting to try to understand why we find one song irresistible to dance to and another… not.

Personally, I don't play any songs with this modern cymbal sound– not because I'm such a purist, but because they just don't make me want to dance. They make me want to relax and have a drink. That feeling is the way I decide, not something technical.

DJs, what do you think?

Do you hear these differences as significant, or am I making a lot out of nothing? Do you find it jarring when very modern-sounding recordings are juxtaposed with old ones? Or is it a welcome bit of variety? Do you use this contrast consciously in your DJ sets?

Share
Tweet
Pin
0 Shares

Filed Under: Expertise Tagged With: Glenn Crytzer, Swing Music, Vintage Sound

About Adrian Seward

Adrian has long had a passion for the jazz music of the 20s and 30s. After moving to New Orleans, he began playing this kind of music and learning the dances which go with it. He now lives in Zurich, Switzerland, and writes about music at www.qssi.blogspot.ch. He finds that music and dance present the same kinds of questions that he deals with in his profession of architectural history. He abhors classifying things.

Primary Sidebar

Hello there!

I'm Chris aka DJ Chrisbe and I'm the founder of Swing DJ Resources, where Swing DJs and music lovers connect and get inspired. Join the community!

Search

Recent Posts

  • New Release: “Sailboat In The Moonlight” by Geoff Bull And The Finer Cuts
  • Hey Mister Jesse #170 is now available (März 2020)
  • New Release: “Live!” by Candy Jacket Jazz Band
  • New Release: “Slidkrans” by Cats & Dinosaurs
  • New Release: “Return to The Twenties” by Firecracker Jazz Band

Archives

More Stories

Sailboat In The Moonlight - Geoff Bull And The Finer Cuts

New Release: “Sailboat In The Moonlight” by Geoff Bull And The Finer Cuts

Hey Mister Jesse #170

Hey Mister Jesse #170 is now available (März 2020)

Candy Jacket Jazz Band - Live!

New Release: “Live!” by Candy Jacket Jazz Band

Cats & Dinosaurs - Slidkrans

New Release: “Slidkrans” by Cats & Dinosaurs

Firecracker Jazz Band - Return To The Twenties

New Release: “Return to The Twenties” by Firecracker Jazz Band

Hot Club Of Baltimore feat. Alexis Tantau

New Release: “Hot Club of Baltimore featuring Alexis Tantau”

Miss Mikey May and the Organ Grinders - That's That!

New Release: “That’s That” by Miss Mikey May and the Organ Grinders

O Sister! - Nobody Cares

New Release: “Nobody Cares” by O Sister!

The Raggedy Junkers - Out Of Steam

New Release: “Out Of Steam” by The Raggedy Junkers

The Bailsmen - From Up Top

New Release: “From Up Top” by The Bailsmen

Le Dancing Pepa Jazz Band - Dancin' in Storyville

New Release: “Dancin’ in Storyville” by Le Dancing Pepa Swing Band

Jeremy Mohney - Let Go

New Release: “Let Go” by Jeremy Mohney

Hey Mister Jesse Podcast #168

Hey Mister Jesse #169 is now available (February 2020)

Just Jivin' by Savoy Satellites

New Release: “Just Jivin'” by Savoy Satellites

Hey Mister Jesse #168

Hey Mister Jesse #168 is now available (January 2020)

Enric Peidro Swingtet Meets Jessie Gordon

New Release: “Enric Peidro Swingtet Meets Jessie Gordon”

The Changepartners Orchestra - 5 Years EP

New Release: “5 Years EP” by The Changepartners Orchestra

Harmony In Harlem by The Jeepers

New Release: “Harmony In Harlem” by The Jeepers

Live At The Uptown Swingout

New Release: “Live at the Uptown Swingout” by Naomi & Her Handsome Devils

Hot Sugar Band - 3 Unreleased Originals

New Release: “3 Unreleased Originals” by Hot Sugar Band

The Sphynx by Jonathan Ng

New Release: “The Sphynx” by Jonathan Ng

Alec Haavik & The Shanghai Shindiggers

New Release: “Alec Haavik & The Shanghai Shindiggers”

Alex-Pangman - If I Don't Mean It

New Release: “If I Don’t Mean It” by Alex Pangman

Hey Mister Jesse #167

Hey Mister Jesse #167 is now available (December 2019)

Footer

About The Editor

Chris aka DJ Chrisbe is the founder and editor-in-chief of Swing DJ Resources and Shuffle Projects. Since 2006, he has been DJing all over Europe and abroad. Follow him on Twitter. Read More…

Recent Comments

  • Christian Bossert on New Release: “Shirt Tail Bounce” by Shirt Tail Stompers feat. Luca Filastro
  • Queebers on New Release: “Shirt Tail Bounce” by Shirt Tail Stompers feat. Luca Filastro
  • Jp Mc Glynn on New Release: “Steppin On The Gas” by Shotgun Jazz Band
  • Christian Bossert on Traktor Audio 2 now also supports Traktor DJ on iOS Devices
  • Brennan Bowman on Traktor Audio 2 now also supports Traktor DJ on iOS Devices

Archives

Search

Support us on Patreon

Become a Patron!

Copyright © 2012–2021 Shuffle Projects · On Genesis Framework · Hosting: WP Engine · Log in